Deciding whether to restore, remodel or rebuild an Eichler or other mid-century house is largely a question of rules and reversibility. The same project can be routine on one lot and need design review on the next, and a few original features are very hard to put back once they're gone.
This guide defines the three paths the way building codes and preservation documents do, explains which rules can shape each one, and lists the features worth protecting whichever path you choose. It's about architecture and rules. It makes no claims about what any path does to a house's value. For each city's rules side by side, see Eichler design rules by city, and for upgrades in detail, energy efficiency in mid-century homes.
Three paths, in the code's terms
Restore. Repair and in-kind replacement. Under California's Energy Code, a repair is maintenance that doesn't increase energy use, and the code doesn't apply to it. Replacing a regulated part, such as a roof covering or a window, counts as an alteration. Palo Alto's Eichler guidelines give a full chapter to repairs and in-kind replacement, based on the Secretary of the Interior's Standards.
Remodel. Alterations and additions. An addition is any change that increases conditioned floor area and volume, and the state's compliance manual lists converting a garage into living space as one. An alteration is a change to the envelope or to the heating, water heating, lighting or electrical systems.
Rebuild. A new house. The compliance manual notes that an alteration can be so extensive that the local enforcement agency treats it as a newly constructed building, for example a project that removes all wallboard, insulation and exterior walls.
Property tax draws a similar line. The State Board of Equalization lists additions, and rebuilding after taking a house down to its foundation and studs, as new construction. The San Mateo County Assessor says like-for-like replacement and maintenance don't qualify. Under state law, only the newly built portion gets a new base year value. This is general information, not tax or legal advice; ask your county assessor about a specific project.
Find out which rules apply to the lot
Before choosing a path, find out what governs the lot. In Silicon Valley's Eichler tracts, the main layers are these:
Historic districts. The National Park Service says National Register listing places no restrictions on a non-federal owner unless federal funding or permits are involved. Cities can add their own review. San Jose's 2019 memo on the Fairglen Additions said that once the homes were on the city's Historic Resources Inventory, exterior changes would need discretionary review through a Single-Family House Permit.
Objective design standards. San Jose's Eichler standards, approved December 2, 2025, apply to Eichler tracts on that inventory, which as of 2025 meant only the Fairglen Additions. In the version presented to the council, raising a roof above its original height is prohibited and second-story additions are strongly discouraged. Palo Alto's Two-Story Objective Design Standards, effective February 14, 2025, cover new two-story homes and second-story additions, and they limit roof pitches in mapped Eichler tracts to 3:12 or less.
Single-story overlays. Palo Alto's and Sunnyvale's overlays limit houses to one habitable floor and a height of 17 feet, with a higher limit in Palo Alto's flood hazard areas. Our single-story overlay guide explains how owners apply for one.
Guidelines and zoning. Palo Alto's Eichler guidelines are voluntary and say second-story additions are generally discouraged. A Sunnyvale staff report says design review decisions in Eichler neighborhoods must be compatible with the city's Eichler guidelines, which don't prohibit two-story additions. Cupertino's R1-e zoning for the Fairgrove tract sets mandatory rules, such as a 3:12 maximum roof slope.
Our guide to whether a house is historic in California explains how to check the state and local lists.
What's hard to reverse
Restoring is simplest when the original fabric is still there. The Greenmeadow National Register nomination, whose survey judged each house from the street, and San Jose's standards point to the same short list:
The post-and-beam frame. The Greenmeadow survey counted beams cut to non-rectangular shapes against a house. San Jose's standards require keeping exposed beam ends, roof decking and wood fascia, and they prohibit boxing in the beam ends. See our post on post-and-beam repair.
The glass walls and window pattern. Palo Alto's guidelines ask owners to keep limited glass at the front and expansive glass at the rear, and not to divide full-height rear windows or fill in openings. Greenmeadow's survey counted added street-facing windows that don't match the original style against a house, and San Jose prohibits removing walls that face an atrium or courtyard.
The roof line. Greenmeadow's survey counted noticeable changes of pitch, and atrium covers that significantly alter the roofline, against a house. Palo Alto asks owners to keep the narrow roof edge and the overhangs.
The paneling. Interior walls in Greenmeadow were deep-toned Philippine mahogany veneer paneling. San Jose's standards don't cover interiors, so inside the house the decision is the owner's. Our guide to restoring mahogany paneling covers repair and refinishing.
The slab. Palo Alto's guidelines note that adding a basement means demolishing the original slab and removing the radiant heating in it.
Remodeling without losing the house: the Fairglen record
The Fairglen Additions nomination shows how remodels played out across one San Jose district. The main alterations were enclosed carports and garages, added sloped (4:12) roofs and second stories. Where those changes kept the one-story massing and the dominant flat or low-sloped roofs with deep overhangs over exposed beams, the houses still conveyed their historic associations. Where additions erased the one-story massing and the roof forms, the houses were counted as non-contributors, though the nomination judged those additions reversible. In all, the nomination counted 204 of the 218 homes as retaining their architectural integrity, and at least three that suffered substantial fire damage were restored to their original designs. To judge how much of one house is original, see our guide to reading an Eichler like a historic survey.
Palo Alto's guidelines give the design version of the same advice: an addition should be compatible with the original house without directly imitating it, and they suggest post-and-beam framing for additions. Our Fairglen Additions guide covers the district's background.
Permits, energy rules and hazardous materials
Each path brings its own paperwork and checks:
Energy Code. Additions and alterations must comply; repairs don't. Our guide to Title 24 addition requirements covers additions and garage conversions.
Lead. The EPA requires anyone paid to do work that disturbs paint in housing built before 1978 to be certified.
Asbestos. The EPA says you can't tell asbestos by looking and that a trained, accredited professional should take samples. Federal OSHA rules presume that thermal system insulation and surfacing material in buildings built by 1980 contain asbestos, and treat asphalt and vinyl flooring installed by then the same way unless shown otherwise.
The paper trail. Pull the permit history before you design, so you know which earlier changes were permitted and which may need attention.
From our listings
Fairglen homes we’ve sold
This guide’s remodel record comes from the Fairglen Additions nomination in San Jose. These listing photos show homes we’ve sold in Fairglen, as each looked when it was listed. Photos from the listings of five mid-century homes the Boyenga Team has sold in San Jose.

Fairglen, San JoseAtrium · Sold 2019 
Fairglen, San JoseAtrium at dusk · Sold 2024 
Fairglen, San JoseWood island kitchen · Sold 2024 
Fairglen, San JoseBrick fireplace · Sold 2024 
Fairglen, San JoseCovered walk and lawn · Sold 2012 
Fairglen, San JoseLow roof and glass walls · Sold 2012
Listing photographs of homes sold by the Boyenga Team. More homes we’ve sold
See our portfolioFrequently asked questions
Does a National Register listing stop me from remodeling?
Not by itself. The National Park Service says federal listing places no restrictions on a non-federal owner unless federal funding or permits are involved. A city can add its own review, as San Jose did for the Fairglen Additions, so check with the planning department.
Can I add a second story to an Eichler?
It depends on the lot. A single-story overlay limits the house to one habitable floor, San Jose's standards strongly discourage second stories in inventory-listed tracts, and Palo Alto's guidelines generally discourage them, while Sunnyvale's guidelines don't prohibit them. In Greenmeadow's survey, a second story that wasn't original counted against a house's historic standing.
When does a remodel become a rebuild?
The local enforcement agency, usually the city's building department, decides. The state's Energy Code compliance manual says a project that removes all wallboard, insulation and exterior walls could be treated as a newly constructed building rather than an alteration. If you plan to strip a house to the frame, ask the city early.
The Boyenga Team at Compass, led by Eric and Janelle Boyenga, has been in Silicon Valley real estate since 1996, with 2,520+ homes sold and $2.6+ billion in sales. If you're weighing a restoration, remodel or rebuild of a mid-century house, call or text (408) 373-1660 or (650) 383-8606, or contact the Boyenga Team.
Related reading
Eichler plan library: our plan guides, plan records and architect pages in one index
Eichler renovation guide: our owner’s manual, with the renovation guides grouped by system
Selling a Mid-Century Modern Home: What to Fix and What to Leave
Mid-Century Modern Kitchen Remodel: Keep the Architecture Intact
Pricing an Architectural Home When the Comparables Don't Match